top of page

What's the first test for General Synod?

Oct 29
5 min read

Updated: Oct 30


"What is likely to be the first real test of the General Synod when it meets in a few weeks, in November?" That was the last of a number of straight questions put to two of the Directors of the orthodox grouping, the Alliance, when they appeared on an Australian podcast, 'The Pastor's Heart', earlier this week.

Revd Dominic Steele, the host of the podcast, is a former radio journalist, who is now the Senior Minister at Village Church, Annandale, Sydney. This time the hearts in question belonged to the Revd John Dunnett, the National Director of the Church of England's Evangelical Council and the Revd Vaughan Roberts, the Rector of St Ebbe's Oxford.

The title of the podcast was - "Will God save the Church of England?" - and in the light of the recent synod elections both interviewees were cautiously optimistic.

Dunnett was heartened by the voting patterns in a number of dioceses, ".. I think what we can say is that we have strengthened the position of orthodoxy on the Synod... we won't know exactly how much we've strengthened it until we have the first important, as it were, dividing vote."

While Roberts dismissed those who had said that the Alliance was, "purely a marriage of convenience," and asserted that the results show that, "The Alliance is real - that there's a real partnership - and it's deepening - and it is also supported right across the nation."

There may be truth in both these claims, but it is worth remembering that the liberal grouping, 'Together for the Church of England', have said very similar things about their own results.

Both Roberts and Dunnett were candid about the state of the Church of England. Vaughan said it was "a mess", and in an "unsustainable limbo state". He went on to explain how this was because the Prayers of Love and Faith allow for, "the blessing of sin", so "a significant red line's already been crossed". John Dunnett was even more frustrated about the current situation,"... to be blunt, we've had a number of bishops who have reassured us that they are theologically orthodox, but I'm left thinking, 'I don't quite understand what you mean by that given the way you voted in previous votes'."

The interviewer sought to find out how the Alliance intended to work within that limbo. He was told there was a general agreement, amongst the leadership, on the principle of breaking spiritual fellowship with those who commend sin, while recognising that people's, "conscience and context," may lead to different actions. The Alliance have adopted the idea of a "de facto parallel province" to describe a number of measures parishes are taking to appear to separate themselves from the spiritual leadership of their bishops, without leaving the Church of England. Dunnett and Roberts advocated for individuals and churches to have freedom to take advantage of whatever aspects of this approach suit them, while continuing to argue for "a more fixed and permanent arrangement".

Two important matters arise from this, which will have implications for orthodox folk in the Church of England.

The first is that, while Dominic Steele seemed enamoured by irregular ordinations at St Helen's, Bishopsgate, both of the others appeared to see at least some of the problems with this pathway. Yet, at the same time, John Dunnett said that the Church of England Evangelical Council is exploring what other,"irregular but lawful," actions they may take. This suggests that the next five years may be marked by a complete breakdown of order from both the orthodox and liberal wings of the church, which could have serious consequences for the future of a healthy Anglican church. Once clergy become accustomed to ignoring their bishops, in favour of an unofficial 'spiritual overseer', the task of restoring appropriate canonical relationships in the future becomes much harder.

Second, neither Dunnett nor Roberts were willing to set out what kind of 'settlement' the Alliance would accept. The clearest comments came from Vaughan Roberts, who said that in the long term it would be impossible to work with, "... suffragan bishops, who are orthodox, under liberal [diocesan] bishops, because that models a system which implies a partnership that we we can't accept."  Still, neither mentioned the possibility of a permanent third province, which may be because they have recognised the intractable difficulties involved in such a plan. This suggests they are working on some kind of 'non-geographic extra-diocesan' solution on the table - perhaps akin to that put forward by this blog three years ago.

After about 27 minutes of discussion, Dominic Steele posed his last question - What is likely to be the first real test of the General Synod when it meets in a few weeks, in November?"  

To which Vaughan Roberts gave a rather woolly answer, focusing on votes that may or may not happen in the coming years. This missed the mark by some way.

It may be that Roberts was being discreet, but this gave the impression that the leadership of the Alliance may have not have recognised the importance of the Service of Holy Communion, at Westminster Abbey, which marks the inaugeration of the new Synod. This will take place on the 17th November.

It is difficult to think of a more obvious sign of spiritual fellowship than the sharing of the bread and wine. The very bishops who they claim to have no spiritual fellowship with will be present at Westminster Abbey. There will be many in the congregation who are unrepentantly campaigning to tear the doctrine of the Church of England away from its biblical foundations. It will be an 'open table'.

The orthodox members therefore have a choice to make. While the efficacy of the sacrament is not in question, they will need to decide how they register their broken spiritual fellowship.

Some may chose not to attend the service at all. But for those who take their seat, the question is whether they will they remain in it during the administration of Holy Communion. The alternative will be to go with the flow and receive the bread and wine alongside those they know to be living in sustained open disobedience.

It should not, of course, be their choice to make. The bishops of the Church of England should not be leading the church astray and should have carried out appropriate discipline, in accordance with Canon B16. This allows for bishops to refuse to admit those living in, "grave and open sin without repentance," to the table, for two reasons:

"...first to ensure that there is no appearance of communion between the thoroughly repentant and those in grave and open sin, when no such communion can actually exist, and secondly to encourage any in such sin to repent.  Failing to uphold the Canon therefore both excludes the repentant from the Lord’s table, and shows a lack of true compassion for the unrepentant."

Those orthodox members of General Synod who choose to remain seated will be in august company. This, after all, was the costly decision taken by the bishops of the Global South Fellowship of Anglicans, at the Lambeth Conference. Several blogs were written at the time, including this one by Dr Martin Davie, commending their actions. There is also a precedent at General Synod. In 2016, a number of orthodox members stayed seated during Holy Communion, having previously asked the Archbishop of Canterbury to exercise appropriate discipline, only to be told they were, "the problem".

Those who choose to take communion, need to recognise that it will be understood as a visible sign that despite all the rhetoric there is shared spiritual fellowship, and thus it may undermine their requests for a settlement based on alternative episcopal oversight.

So, in answer to Dominic Steele's question: the first real test, and probably the most important test, for the orthodox members of General Synod will take place in Westminster Abbey at approximately 11.30am on the 17th November 2026.

Set an alarm now to pray for them then.


Photo by James Coleman on Unsplash

Join us online - November 12th at 2.30pm or 7.30pm

for our pre-Synod

Anglican Update






4 Comments


Graham Hamilton
7 days ago

Thank you for this article. I intend to remain seated at Westminster on Tuesday. I would like to know the source of your quotation above, which is not from the text of Canon B16, but is very helpful: ""...first to ensure that there is no appearance of communion between the thoroughly repentant and those in grave and open sin, when no such communion can actually exist, and secondly to encourage any in such sin to repent.  Failing to uphold the Canon therefore both excludes the repentant from the Lord’s table, and shows a lack of true compassion for the unrepentant."

Like
Replying to

It is a quote from the letter sent by some Synod members to the Archbishop of Canterbury in 2015.

Like

Graham Cotter
Nov 02

Thank you very much for your article. I fully agree with you about this first test, and the need to step back from participating in Holy Communion, and to indicate clearly that there is broken spiritual fellowship. When attending Exeter Cathedral in support of orthodox ordinands whom I have got to know, I remain seated at the time of Holy Communion, in the light of a Diocesan Bishop who is set on gender neutral blessing and marriage.

When in parish ministry we invited young Egyptian believers to join us every summer, and a key factor in my mind is identification with Archbishop Mouneer Anis. 'What would Mouneer do if he were sitting alongside me?' He would not be participating, and…

Like
Replying to

Thank you for this practical example of faithfulness. Please pray on for all involved.

Like

Anglican Futures

Office 7, 20 Lostwithiel Street, Fowey, PL23 1BE

info@anglicanfutures.org 

Tel: 07851 596888

Registered Charity in England and Wales (1192663)

© 2020 by Anglican Futures with Wix.com

bottom of page