Two Visions of Communion : Gafcon and the Nairobi-Cairo Proposals

As bishops and church leaders gather in Abuja, Nigeria for the 2026 Gafcon Council, another conversation about the future of the Anglican Communion is unfolding at the same time. The Anglican Consultative Council (ACC) announced that it will consider revised versions of the Nairobi–Cairo proposals later this year, structural reforms intended to rethink how the Communion is organized and how authority is exercised across its global fellowship of provinces.

The timing is striking. While Gafcon leaders meet to reaffirm their vision for Anglican unity and identity, the Communion’s official institutions are considering their own attempt to address the fractures that have defined Anglican life for nearly two decades. Whether these efforts represent parallel responses to the same crisis, or competing visions of Anglicanism’s future, remains an open question, but we suspect a purposeful step to undermine Gafcon's G26 conference. We’ve seen this before in the Church of England, and that battle is moving onto the world stage.

At the first press briefing of the gathering in Abuja, the Rev. Canon Justin Murff, Communications Director for Gafcon, addressed a question that followed the movement since its founding in 2008: whether it represents a break from the Anglican Communion. “The goal is not to break apart the Communion,” Murff said. “This is a claim to continuum.” Murff emphasized that the movement continues to define itself through the Jerusalem Declaration, the theological statement adopted at the first Gafcon gathering in Jerusalem. Far from being merely a protest against developments in the Western churches, he said, the declaration was intended to articulate what unites Anglicans who believe the Communion must remain rooted in the authority of Scripture. “We will be reaffirming and upholding the Jerusalem Declaration,” Murff said. “It is not designed to show what we oppose but what unites Gafcon.”

For many within the movement, the declaration has increasingly functioned as a theological centre of gravity for Anglicans who believe the Communion has struggled to address doctrinal divisions that have widened in recent decades. “It has become a basis of communion across boundaries,” Murff said, noting that it provides theological grounding for cooperation, and, at times, cross-provincial oversight, among churches that share the same doctrinal commitments. Murff insisted that Gafcon does not see itself as creating a new church. Instead, he suggested that many within the movement believe they are preserving the historic faith of Anglicanism even as the Communion’s institutional structures struggle to respond to theological conflict. “We are the Anglican Communion,” he said, describing the movement as committed to “defending the faith as the Word of God has taught and commanded.”

At the same time, Murff pushed back against portrayals of Gafcon as primarily defined by opposition to contemporary cultural debates. He described the purpose of Gafcon as not being to come against the LGBTQ+ movement or other social issues. Gafcon is more about what the Anglican Communion is, rather than what it is not. “We are,” he stated, “a Communion centered around the Bible.” The deeper issue, he suggested, concerns authority within the global church. Many Gafcon leaders believe the Communion’s current structures allow a relatively small group of Western provinces, representing a minority of the world’s Anglicans, to exercise disproportionate influence over the direction of the wider body. “The Church should exercise democratic rights and values in the Communion,” Murff said, rather than allowing a small Western church with limited global representation to set the tone for the entire fellowship.

Questions inevitably turned to the Church of England and the historic role of the Archbishop of Canterbury as a focal point of Anglican unity. Asked whether current tensions could eventually lead to a definitive break with Canterbury, Murff offered a striking response: “The invitation is always open to England to join us.” The remark reflects a perspective increasingly heard within the movement, that Gafcon represents not a departure from Anglicanism but an effort to preserve its historic theological identity.

Yet the Communion’s own structures are also beginning to wrestle with the same global realities.

The Nairobi–Cairo proposals now before the Anglican Consultative Council explore ways to rethink how the Communion is described and governed. Among other ideas, the proposals suggest framing Anglican unity less in terms of formal communion with the See of Canterbury and more in terms of shared inheritance, mutual service, and common counsel among provinces. They also raise the possibility of distributing leadership more broadly across the Communion, rather than centering it primarily on the Archbishop of Canterbury.

Yet their most recent proposal, for the Archbishop of Canterbury to share leadership with five 'regional' Primates, is far from democratic. It is laughable that of the six members of such a group, three would be from the tiny provinces found in Europe and the Americas, while only one would represent the whole of Africa.

Whatever the immediate motivation for the Nairobi–Cairo proposals, the moment itself is unmistakable. The future structure and identity of the Anglican Communion are now being considered in several places at once. Conversations about authority, unity, and accountability are unfolding both within the “official” institutions of the Communion and among movements such as Gafcon that have sought to articulate a theological centre for global Anglicanism.

Despite the post-colonial bias of the ACC, the attention of the wider church increasingly turns toward the Global South, where the majority of the world’s Anglicans now live and where many of the provinces most active in Gafcon are located. The direction these churches choose in the years ahead, whether through institutional reform, theological alignment, or some combination of both, will help determine what Anglican communion means in the twenty-first century.

Anglican Futures offers more than a blog

Join us online to discuss the events and implications of G26

Thursday 12th March 7.30pm

Sign up here.